“Spectacles of Power and Faith: Colonial South American Art from the Thoma Foundation”

by John Zotos
Meadows Museum, SMU, Dallas
Continuing through January 24, 2027

“Spectacles of Power and Faith” is the result of a curatorial collaboration between the Meadows Museum, the Thoma Foundation, and their respective curators Adam Jasienski and Veronica Munoz-Najar. The Foundation, which moved its headquarters to central Dallas in 2023, houses a collection started decades ago by Carl and Marilynn Thoma. Their interests span centuries of Western art such that Old Master works hang alongside modern and contemporary works. For this exhibition sixty-three paintings from colonial Spain in South America dated between 1660 and 1850 take center stage.
In painting after painting, arranged here in several thematic sections, the resolute quality of the work marks this exhibition one of today’s truly exemplary collections of colonial Spanish art. All of the pieces were created in Viceroyal Spain in present day Peru, Bolivia, Colombia, Venezuela, and Ecuador.

Visitors are able to trace the visual history of Western art through two parallel progressions: the Spanish kingdom occupying the Iberian peninsula and the Spanish Americas. In the main gallery an explanatory text makes it clear that the Spaniards took strategic advantage of various lethal diseases, unknowingly introduced into the new world, that decimated ninety percent of the population.
The Spanish easily pacified the survivors and began a colonial program of acquiring resources and amassing great wealth. This included subduing what they could of indigenous religious beliefs and practices, which they replaced with a colonial Catholic hybrid. “Spectacles of Power and Faith” argues that this was easier said than done. Attempts to teach “culture” in the form of European art to the locals resulted in an adaptive resistance such that local customs and traditions blended with those brought by the colonizers. This resulted in an art that is “Europeanate” rather than European as such. When the viceroyalties began to demand European visual trappings like easel paintings and polychrome wooden sculpture, the colonial overlords found that local traditions rooted in textile design, ceramics, and metallurgy were an unbreakable force. As such, the South American artists who were expected to adopt styles that privileged naturalism and Catholic iconography ended up innovating the art by adapting it to local traditions. This fusion, as the show attests, resulted in completely original artworks.

The exhibition begins with a foundational European style of devotional painting by Bernardo Bitti, an Italian priest trained as a Mannerist painter. His “Jesus, Mary, and Joseph” (1600) is a typical painting by a European transplant to Peru, where Bitti arrived in 1572 to spread Catholic dogma through teaching both the faith and painting. This picture is a standard arrangement of the Virgin Mary and Christ child, taking up most of the central frame, with Joseph peering over her right shoulder. Bitti introduces something that runs through the exhibition, an innovative technique that developed in South American painting known as brocateado, or the application of gold onto the surface. The gold adds opulence and a shimmering effect intended to reflect candlelight as a devotional experience. Bitti’s works of art furnished churches and the homes of wealthy patrons and became a reference point to Andean artists for the following two centuries.
As an example of what followed, a painting by an unidentified artist titled “Our Lady of Mercy, Called ‘The Pilgrim of Quito,’ Entering a Town” (1730-35) depicts a group of friars carrying a devotional sculpture of a Virgin and Child that takes center stage. The image intensifies the textile patterns and brocateado such that a new iconography supersedes the European model originally presented to a succeeding generation of artists. The foreground is adorned with flowers, architecture fills the background, and friars of the Mercedarian order, derived from Our Lady of Mercy, conduct a procession to raise money.
“Portrait of King Charles II of Spain as a Child” (1667), artist unknown, depicts a resplendent king attired in the height of local fashion. His Habsburg features have been modified into the appearance of a blond haired, blue eyed, Anglo monarch invested with authority conferred by the heavy pattern and ruffles of his dress. His hand rests on a globe meant to signify that the world is his realm.

At the time, paintings like this represented the monarchy, since no Spanish king ever set foot in the New World. However, such a fantasized depiction of the king could engender more respect and adoration in its target viewers than a standard image ever could. Royal portraits like this one were stand-ins for the crown. They presided over legal proceedings, public ceremonies, and could even pardon criminals. Ironically, as the son of King Philip IV, King Charles II was the last Spanish Habsburg on the throne, bringing an end to two centuries of rule in both hemispheres. Charles failed to produce an heir due to infertility, a byproduct of the family’s corrupted gene pool, and ultimately died insane.
For all the imperialist confabulation, there was no figure in South American devotional practices more important than the Virgin Mary, whose various depictions took on their own style of painting known as Marian advocations. Each one had an origin story and was attached to a specific community with a distinct iconography, usually related to a miracle that became legend. They often created powerful followings related to pilgrimage and economic prosperity that also drove artistic production.
“Our Lady of Bethlehem of Cuzco with Donor” (18th century) is the finest example in the exhibition. This imposing seven-foot-tall painting, complete with heavily patterned brocateado, devotes most of its pictorial space to the Virgin and Child. As an original example serving as a model for countless later paintings, these Marian images typically include a pyramidal golden gown that only reveals the Virgin’s head at the tip, her hands, and only the Christ child’s head; the rest is ornament. This one includes an unidentified donor, a distinctly Andean gentleman, in a more natural and modeled style that contrasts with an otherwise flat sensibility throughout. This image actually represents a sculpture of the Lady of Bethlehem that is carried through the streets to celebrate the feast of Corpus Christi. Other examples of Marian advocations include “Our Lady of Cocharcas” (present-day Peru), “Our Lady of Copacabana” (Bolivia), and “Our Lady of Chiquinquira” (Colombia).
As a contribution to the study and experience of South American colonial art, “Spectacles of Power and Faith” is an invaluable resource to the field. It masterfully illustrates the originality and richness of the period by clearly delineating how it diverged from what came before it. The show and its contents compels scholars to continue to unravel the complexity and rich depth of an art form that, throughout most of the continent, held sway for over two centuries.
John Zotos is an art critic and essayist based in Dallas.





Comments